"Day by day remind yourself that you are going to die." ~Rule of Benedict, 4:47 (RB 1980 translation)
Last evening I spoke on the phone with my aged mother who lives in a distant state. She updated me, as always, on the details of her daily existence. But along with the mundane was the news that yet another of her oldest friends has passed away. I have received similar news from her multiple times in recent years. My mother was fortunate to have belonged to a group of friends from her teenage years, who kept in touch all their lives, no matter the distance in miles between them, nor the time passed since they had seen each other face to face. I don't know the exact number in the group, but it was in the 8 to 10 range, I think. I think these life long friendships are one of the things that made my mother into the champion letter writer that I have always known her to be. If you receive a letter from my mother, you can count on it being several pages in length. Being of a certain age and habit, she still writes long letters faithfully...an almost dead art in this age of e-mail and text messaging, neither of which my aged mother knows much about nor would she care to....
So I have heard this particular sadness in her voice before. But if anything, last night it was even more poignant. "It's only your Aunt V. and me now," she said. My Aunt V. was also in this same group of friends. The inevitability of her coming death is something that my mother lives with every day. She hardly needs to hear St. Benedict's admonition above, given to the monks of his monastery, and passed on for centuries to their spiritual descendants in his "Rule for Monks."
Is it only upon reaching "middle age" that most of us really begin to think about the reality of our own death? When we wake up one day and realize that barring accident or disease (which, of course, can take anyone at any age)--were we to live out a life of "normal" longevity--we have now passed a point...we are closer to our graves than to our cradles.
I'm certainly no stranger to such ponderings. Ironically perhaps (but not surprisingly really, if you stop to think about it) such "reflection on death" actually makes one think very deeply and intentionally about one's life. When a realization of the universal truth of one's coming death hits home (as we seldom allow it to?), one tends to examine the trajectory of one's life more carefully.... If all goes well, I may have X years left...how shall I then live? And this is exactly the sort of sober introspection--about one's life--that Benedict meant to inspire in his monks. As an aside of sorts, I should probably mention here that although I am no longer an adherent to their religion (or to any "religion" for that matter), I remain deeply indebted to the Benedictines for my education, not simply for a degree earned in their institution, but for the lessons in a thoughtful, contemplative, and deeply environmentally and locally conscious life in community that I imbibed from my years of association with them. And honestly, while I have little time for most things "Christian" anymore (and neither offense nor disrespect is meant to any believers who read this), the Benedictines retain my deepest respect.
But back to reflecting upon death.... Recently I have begun to have other thoughts about death and it's inevitability. It is not only ourselves who will die. It is all who are dear to us. I think my mother's phone call last night drove home that obvious (yet elusive?) truth... And in fact, it is not only all who are dear to us that will die. It is everything that is dear to us.... Yes, I think so. At the very least, I find this to be true in my own life.
There is more that I could say here today about this, but I think I'll leave it right there for now. Perhaps I'll revisit these thoughts in another post, a "part two." No guarantees though. The words come when they come (as was alluded to in a couple of previous posts and their comment threads especially) and remain silent when they remain in the silence. At least I will try to live by that....
All things arise, bloom and grow, and then wither and pass away. All things.
All things. I am increasingly at peace with this....Once again, I don't know anyone who has said what is closest to my heart and mind on a matter better than Mr. Berry (and for the umpteenth time such that perhaps you tire of him here....), and so, I close with his reflections. I have bolded the last line, and it is what I have titled this post. A patient willing descent into the grass. And may I leave no trace save one.
The Wish to Be Generous
Wendell Berry
All that I serve will die, all my delights,
the flesh kindled from my flesh, garden and field,
the silent lilies standing in the woods,
the woods, the hill, the whole earth, all
will burn in man's evil, or dwindle
in its own age. Let the world bring on me
the sleep of darkness without stars, so I may know
my little light taken from me into the seed
of the beginning and the end, so I may bow
to mystery, and take my stand on the earth
like a tree in a field, passing without haste
or regret toward what will be, my life
a patient willing descent into the grass.

22 comments:
I visited my Uncle a few years back, just two days after his getting the news that he may not see three weeks- his heart was giving out- (he lasted another ten months... doctors...pffft)
but what he said to me was at once the most absurdly funny, and yet for him in that moment, absolutely true thing that Ive ever heard him say... he said: "I never thought Id ever get to this point in my life"...
well DUH!
I was laughing inside, and I was able to be completely present for his fear as well...
but the sheer WISDOM of that... and the utter humor of the "duh" of it!
I see- Ive been seeing for some time... death is not a thing that will come "some day"... well, it is for our brains, yes, which are constrained to that whole time thing... you know- before and after, now and later, past and future...
but if we can put time in a quiet place- for just a few moments even... then we would see it... death is here- now... always has been... we really were "dying" the moment we were born...
I recommend taking the monks advice here- and dont allow that to become trite or cute or clever... but really to SEE it... death is here now... look- and we'll see it...
"You only live twice
once when you're born,
and once again when you look death in the face" ~ Ian Flemming
Over the weekend I read somewhere (! - possibly one of Robert Fisk's columns, but I can't locate it) of a young Palestinian girl/woman who was running from Israeli gunfire. She was about 20 years old, beautiful, healthy, in the full bloom of her life. As she ran away from the gunfire, she was screaming, "No, no, no!"
The outrage of her life ending now, at this moment, was beyond her comprehension, something that she could not accept and that every fiber in her being defied.
And yet she was killed. Her life ended in that moment.
There was no time to prepare, no willing descent into the grass.
This image has haunted me the last couple of days. Not only to the horror of war, but to the very violence of death itself. Can any of us really prepare for this?
Of course, as death becomes closer, and our bodies wear out, it begins to be more acceptable, more natural, even.
But what of the girl who cried NO?
Tom,
Thank you for this. Thank you for taking the time to say this here. There is truth and wisdom in what you write. Yes, the advice from Benedict is good. And death is with us here and now, not (just) at some future cessation of brain activity. Thank you for making me think. Peace.
Beth,
I realize the following is not a satisfactory answer, but:
I don't know.
But perhaps I'll say one word of explaination:
Context.
All meaning is dependent upon context.
It is certainly true that the context of this girls murder is very different than the context of Berry's "patient willing descent inton the grass."
Beyond that I do not have an answer for you, if an answer was what you were seeking.
As always, I deeply appreciate your being here to engage the discussion though.
Peace to you, my friend.
What a beautiful post...and Beth's comment has provoked me into deep thought...to descend into the grass is perhaps what some? or all would want?
...but death has many forms, as too in nature..the chopping down of trees..the prey of wild animals...
So, I suppose like another poem on death "rage against the dying of the light"...however unfair and abhorrent the girl's death, she was expressing rage or full life against it....
Thinking contextually, would raging against your death be equally as acceptable as slowly descending into the grass, depending on the context?
For some deeply peaceful and gentle souls, of couse, the beauty of descending into the grass would be the preferred option.
Bella
(not sure if my musings make sense)
Bella,
I think your thoughts expressed here make sense, and I thank you for sharing them.
You ask if "raging against your death" could "be equally as acceptable as slowly descending into the grass, depending on the context?"
Well, while I am the one who brought the idea of context into this discussion...I'm going to say "I don't know" again.
And lest you think I'm just "copping out" on an answer, perhaps my "leaning" on this question will be discernable from the follwoing continuation of my commentary.
I'll be honest and say that I have never liked the Dylan Thomas poem "rage against the dying of the light." I've always found it quite grasping and actually even rather arrogant in its tone.
Call it detachment or whatever you like, but when my own time comes to die, tomorrow, or many years from now, and be it even by a murderer's hand rather than patiently descending into the grass, I will simply go, there will be no raging. I refuse to rage, I refuse to grasp.... And so, perhaps for me the context will actually make little difference. I go willingly when it's time to go.
Forest:
Some years ago I was misdiagnosed with a certain fatal disease. I was in my twenties, had just “found” myself, figured out what I wanted to do in life, bought a house, had the world by the tail, an open road ahead.
Then THE NEWS. OHMYGOD!
Sure, I knew about death, had been in the room when death took friends, family. Had watched death happen in the form of various horrors—disease, war, accident, self. Death was real. A fact. And, honestly, I knew it would come for me one day.
But I hadn’t expected it so soon. Not when I was just getting started. And so—and this is, in retrospect, almost funny—I went into such a “why me?” funk that it almost killed me. For nearly a year I sat around, sick, hurting, expecting to just get worse and then die, and I wasn’t so much angry as I was disappointed—disappointed not at what I’d done, but what I’d not done. Disappointed that I’d not lived the right life—my life. I hadn’t “found” myself—I’d found some goofy, success-driven idiot I didn’t even like. I’d gotten caught up in doing the expected, playing it safe, being responsible to others, not myself and those I loved.
I had dreams, craved adventures. The safe, normal, expected life wasn’t me. I’d failed myself…my gifts…my expectations, terribly. What a stupid, play-it-safe mistake. And look where’d it had gotten me. And now I’d never have the chance to get it right, take the other fork in the road…be just plain old like-it-or-lump-it me.
Then, I got re-diagnosed. Guess what? You ain’t gonna die after all. Here, take these pills.
And within a couple of weeks, I was better; healed; well! And happy—not angry at anyone, but glad. Glad for a second chance, glad to be alive, and more than anything, glad for the lesson the whole experience taught me. It was the best lesson I’ve ever learned.
Death is out there. But so is life—and the best way to meet the former is to make full use of the latter.
Over the years I’ve watched so many people die. I’ve sat by their beds, held their hands, listened to their last words and breaths. Mystery or comfort? We must each consider, and live our lives accordingly. Like you, I have no desire to die in rage, but rather to die in peace.
A lovely post, my friend. May we both find our answers.
Another sobering thought: 100 hundred years from now, no one you know, and no one who knows you, will be alive.
Grizzled,
Death is out there. But so is life—and the best way to meet the former is to make full use of the latter.
Yes! I heartily agree.
Thank you for sharing your personal story about this.
Paul,
Yes. Good words to ponder. Thank you.
I have nothing poetic to add. I just want to say that I enjoyed your post AND all the comments here. If nothing else, it's more food for thought...
My sister died from a brain tumour in her 20s. My mother died 4 years ago after suffering from Alzheimer's for 5 years. My 90 year father is very ill right now and may be approaching his own death.
To be honest, I'm terrified of dying. Though I think about death most days (not morbidly), I really haven't got my head round the idea at all. I'm in my 50s - but I still feel I'm just starting the journey in many ways. I feel there's so much more to do, see, think, read and experience.
I don't think I'd be very good at dying at all. At the moment I'm much more in the raging, Dylan Thomas mode.
For anyone who may be interested, I wrote about death in my own blog on 7 June and 15 June 2008.
RT,
I am glad this discussion made you think.
SW,
Thank you for yor honesty if what you've shared here. I will check out your post on death. Thanks for letting us know about it.
"Death is out there, but so is life ..."
Like most things, the love for life and the willingness to die are opposing tensions, but they go together. You can't really love life, without a willingness to die for it, and you can't really be willing to die, unless you love life intensely.
The recent suicides of people who lost their fortunes because of financial losses are not about willingness to die - but about cowardice, unwillingness to live.
In the 1964 movie, Zorba the Greek, the narrator literally watches his timber company crash to pieces. He turns to Zorba and asks: "Teach me to dance, will you, Zorba?"
Dancing is living in that very place where you let go of everything, including yourself.
It all leads me to the question - do you love life enough to die for it? Would you lay down your life for another life?
Beth,
Another wonderful thought provoking comment. Your comments challenge me sometimes, and that's a good thing.
The recent suicides of people who lost their fortunes because of financial losses are not about willingness to die - but about cowardice, unwillingness to live.
With that I heartily agree.
As to your ending question, once again I honestly don't know that I can answer it. But don't think I won't be thinking about it, for I most certainly will.
Thanks, Beth.
I feared death until I began to live. And I don't mean living in the sense of my heart is beating. I mean LIVING!
That's about all I can say on this subject.
Val, it may be all you have to say on the subject, but it is well worth saying. Yes! I agree. Well said and thank you.
FW, great post. My husband has taken up a practice of living as though this were his last year of life. He attempts to treat each encounter, conversation, etc, this way, and has gained great benefit from it.
I began reading "The Tibetan Book of Living and Dying" recently, and am really resonating with it. If you haven't read it, maybe open it and flip through a few pages some time at a bookstore. I bet you'ld love it.
Thanks for this thought-provoking and beautiful post.
Molly,
So glad the post resonated with you. Wow, what a practice your husband has adopted there. I will have to think about that. Also, I will check out the Tibetan book of Living and Dying. Thanks.
I know a few people who have taken up hospice work. They accompany people in their dying moments, listening and offering their support. This is not a specifically religious ministry, but not alien to it either.
One fellow indicated how differently people approach death and how it may reflect how they approached life. If you embrace life as gift, you will embrace death that way as well. However it comes, bidden or unbidden.
I have known a number of recent examples among those I have known who exemplified this. I deeply honour their memory and pray I may follow their example.
Incidently, I don't have any negative connotations for Dylan Thomas' expression about raging against the dying of the light, by the way. To me, it connotes a strong desire to live every moment one is given, a visceral life force.
Very interesting post and comments thereupon.
Barbara,
Thank you for sharing this. I find the idea interesting that how one views death may also explain (in part) how one approaches life. It makes sense to me.
Thanks for adding to this very interesting comment thread indeed. :)
I want to die peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather, not screaming in terror like his passengers...
;)
I don't imagine I will enjoy the process of dying, in all likelihood, and I probably won't be able to manage dignity, so I'm hoping humour will smooth the way. :)
Sylvia,
Thank you for the humor and the honesty.
Humour (Canadian spelling this time, just for you ;) will undoubtedly help, I should think.
For me I'll keep working towards a patient, willing descent.
Peace to you
Post a Comment